Ohhh yes đđŠ American Lobsterâsweet, tender, and pure luxury. Whether youâre boiling, steaming, or doing a buttery finish, hereâs the classic way to cook it right and keep that meat perfect.
đŠ Classic American Lobster (Boiled or Steamed)
What to Know First
- American lobster = cold-water lobster (Maine lobster)
- Best cooked live for sweetest flavor
- 1â1ÂŒ lb lobster = 1 generous serving
đŠ How to Cook Lobster
Option 1: Steamed (Best Flavor & Texture)
â Most chefsâ preferred method
Youâll need
- Live lobsters
- Large pot with lid + steamer insert
- 2 inches of water
- Salt
Steps
- Bring water and 1 tbsp salt to a rolling boil.
- Add lobsters headfirst, cover.
- Steam:
- 1 lb lobster: 10â12 minutes
- Add 2â3 minutes per extra pound
- Lobster is done when shells are bright red and tail curls tightly.
Option 2: Boiled (Most Common)
Steps
- Bring a large pot of heavily salted water (like seawater) to a rolling boil.
- Add lobsters headfirst.
- Boil:
- 1 lb lobster: 8â10 minutes
- Add 3 minutes per extra pound
- Remove and drain.
đ§ Serving (The Classic Way)
- Melted butter (must-have đ§)
- Lemon wedges
- Optional: garlic butter or herb butter
How to eat
- Twist off claws & tail
- Crack claws with a cracker
- Pull tail meat out in one piece
- Donât forget the knuckle meatâbest bite!
đ„ Pro Tips
- Do NOT overcook â lobster turns rubbery fast.
- Steam > boil for sweeter meat.
- Humanely cook by placing lobster in freezer 10â15 minutes before cooking.
- Shell color doesnât indicate doneness before cookingâinternal temp should be ~140°F.
Flavor Variations
- Butter-poached lobster: Luxury restaurant style
- Grilled lobster tails: Split, brush with garlic butter
- Lobster roll: Lightly dressed with mayo or warm butter
- Surf & turf: Lobster + steak = unbeatable combo
This is simple, elegant, and unforgettable when done right.
Are you planning to cook it whole, tails only, or turn it into something like lobster rolls or pasta?